Getting your Asian American Comic Strip Published
By James Mar
This article will be about comic strip publishing through someone other than yourself.  Self publishing is a whole other topic as is comic book publishing.  I will be reporting on the interest level of Asian American periodicals on Asian American comic strips and will not get into general syndicate submitting.  I know first hand how difficult it is to get comic strips published.  I've done this before representing myself only to find no Asian American periodical interested in my work, (most of them didn't even respond) but this time, I'm representing the interests for all aspiring Asian American comic strip artists in general.  It's difficult enough just getting people in general to look at your work.  For Asian American cartoonists who are trying to appeal to their own ethnic community, is it any different? Are Asian American periodicals/info sites even willing to entertain comic strip submissions?  Do they have guidelines?  Any standards?  Do they have a salary rate?  Do they even care?  Will history repeat itself???  That's what I'm going to find out.
My plan is to email every Asian American periodical I can get to with an inquiry on their official stance on comic strip submissions.  And hopefully, I'll be able to recieve a positive response from each respectable periodical/info site.
My email to each periodical or information site is going to go something like this:

Dear (Periodical)

Hello, my name is James Mar, I run a website called the Asian American Sequential Artists Resource Guide (www.jamesmarstudio.com/aasarg/home.html).  I'm writing an article on the process of getting Asian American comic strips published in Asian American periodicals.  For the purpose of information, I would like to know what your offical stance is on accepting Asian American comic strip submissions for your periodical. If you could answer these few questions, I would greatly appreciate it.  Is your periodical interested in Asian American comic strip submissions?  If so, can you describe what you look for in a good comic strip?  Do you have any submission guidelines or standards?  What salary rates would you give your comic strip artists?  Any response would be greatly appreciated.  However, please be aware that your entire response or lack of response will be reported in full for the article.

Thank you,
James Mar
Asian American Sequential Artists Resource Guide
Response:
AsianWeek
sent: 12/16/04
to: asianweek@asianweek.com,
vwomack@asianweek.com
Response 12/23/04: AsianWeek is always on the lookout for up and coming Asian American artists, illustrators, and comic strip and comic book creators.
We think comics are an important form of expression and communication. Our interest are in comics that put forth an Asian American perspective and reflect the APA experience. The comics need to be visually interesting. The text must be provocative, compelling and/or funny. We don't have salary rates, and cannot offer hefty compensation. But we do want to support and promote APA creators.  I hope you will be able to send folks our way!
Peace,
Teddy
Editor
tfang@asianweek.com
Response 12/30/04: Any one can submit art material to Alterasian.  It will be used if we feel that it is appropriate for the site.  We also accept links to visual and/or performing arts portfolio/resume. We do not pay contributors however, some will be featured as the front page of the site or a section.

Thank you very much.
AlterAsian
sent: 12/16/04
to: info@alterasian.com
Asian American Movement E-Zine
sent: 12/16/04
to: yellowpower@aamovement.net
Response 12/17/04: We're a progressive political webzine. It's a volunteer operation. We would publish political strips on political issues related to Asian Americans. We don't pay anyone for their submissions at this point.
Thanks.
Azine
Asian American Times
sent: 12/16/04
to: mannywong@cybertrails.com
NO response
Asian Athlete
sent: 12/16/04
to: info@AsianAthlete.com
NO response
Response 12/17/04: Thank you for your email. We are interested in publishing comic strip that is appropriate for our website, however, we will not be able to pay for them since all of our articles are
written by volunteers.  If any of your artists are interested
in "volunteering" their comic strip to gain some exposure, I
would be interested in talking to them.
Many thanks,

Jino Ahn
President
Asian Diversity, Inc.
1270 Broadway, 7th Floor
New York,  NY 10001
tel. 212-465-8777
fax. 212-465-8396
www.ADiversity.com
Asian Diversity Magazine
sent: 12/16/04
to: Jino.Ahn@Diversity.com
Response 12/29/04: Hello! Our magazine is interested in all types of Asian cultural issues, which could include Asian American comic strips.  We don't have any submission guides or standards and we would not pay a salary for a
comic strip artist at this point.  We would however, pay a freelance
artist who would write something specific to Asiance Mag.  Thanks!

Jaymie Moran
Asiance Magazine
sent: 12/16/04
to: Pamelabonifacio@asiancemagazine.com
Asian Connections
sent: 12/16/04
to: info@asianconnections.com (
failed email)
adrates@asianconnections.com (
failed email)
lia@asianconnections.com
NO response
Asian Pages
sent: 12/16/04
to: asianpages@att.net
Response 12/21/04: I welcome comic strip submissions. I'm looking for good humor in day-to-day situations. All material must have a non-offensive Asian slant. We pay $25 per cartoon strip upon publication.  Single panel or multiple (3) panel format accepted.  Submissions with a SASE should be sent to: Cheryl Weiberg, Editor-in-Chief, Asian Pages, PO Box 11932, St. Paul, MN 55111.
--
Asian Pages
The Leading Asian Resource Serving
the Midwest
AsiaXpress
sent: 12/16/04
to: info@asiaxpress.com
NO response
AzAsian
sent: 12/16/04
to: info@azasian.com
NO response
Bamboo Girl
sent: 12/16/04
to: bamboogirl@aol.com
Response 12/17/04:Thanks for inquiring about comic strip submissions, as I would love to see more Asian American comic strip artists out there.  I have published
comic strips by up and coming Asian American artists in the past, and
continue encouraging submissions specifically by Asian Americans.  It's also
interesting because I illustrate all the covers of the zine issues, and therefore, some
folks think I am a predominantly illustrated publication (which actually isn't so.)

Here are the answers to your questions:
Q: Is your periodical interested in Asian American comic strip
submissions?
A: Most definitely, yes.
Q: If so, can you describe what you look for in a good comic strip? 
A: Good art, Good message.
Q: Do you have any submission guidelines or standards? 
A: I'm open to all subject matter, but prefer it to be about the Asian American
experience.  And anything that's racist, sexist, or homophobic will be tossed.
Q: What salary rates would you give your comic strip artists? 
A: Unfortunately, since my publication is a zine, an independently
published and run operation, it is created out of pure passion, and hardly breaks
even.  Because of that, I do not gather any income and am unable to pay
contributors.

Hope that answers your questions.  Feel free to ask if any additional
ones
come up.

Peace,
Sabrina Margarita
bamboo girl zine
pob 507, ny, ny 10159-0507 usa
Dallas Thoi Nay
sent: 12/16/04
to: Anthony_DTN@yahoo.com
Response 1/11/05: Thank you for your interested in our publication DALLAS Thoi Nay. It would be great to have your comic strips in our magazine, but currently, we just don't have the budget. We would be willing to do a trade with you and help promote your comapny in exchange for comic strips. The comic strips must be in good taste and with good humor, no nudity or obscene languages. Absolutely, can not be directly offensive to people. Good luck and looking forward in hearing from you.

Anthony Tran
DALLAS Thoi Nay Magazine
Destroy All Monsters
sent: 12/16/04
to: musashi@destroy-all-monsters.com
NO response
Reponse 12/17/04: The DFW Desi focuses on South Asian news and views - we are a very small operation with a free ezine and volunteer editor - so there are no
salaries paid. However if someone wants to contribute a strip which is pertinent
and in good taste, we can definitely publish it.

Raj Bhandari
The DFW Desi
sent: 12/16/04
to: raj@SilkThreads.com
NO response
Filipino Express
sent: 12/16/04
to: Filexpress@aol.com
NO response
Generation Rice
sent: 12/16/04
to: editor@generationrice.com (
failed email)
Giant Robot
sent: 12/16/04
to: info@giantrobot.com,
eric@giantrobot.com
NO response
NO response
Goldsea.com
sent: 12/16/04
to: info@goldsea.com (
failed email)
(contact on website)
Got Pandesal
sent: 12/16/04
to: info@gotpandesal.com
NO response
Hyphen Magazine
sent: 12/16/04
to: hyphen@hyphenmagazine.com
Response 12/20/04: Your email was forwarded to me by my editor in chief, Melissa Hung.Sorry for the delay in getting back to you. I hope I can help with some of your questions.

Q: Is your periodical interested in Asian American comic strip submissions?  If so, can you describe what you look for in a good comic strip?
A: Yes!!! We devote the last inside page of our book to a different comic every issue and we love to bring new Asian American talent into the spotlight.  Comic submissions are usually directed to me, but occasionally artists have been recommended by someone on the editorial team. As the art director, I generally look for work that is visually appealing first. I am interested in work that is polished and well-developed. I look for creative compositions, strong lines, and good use of color (if it IS in color). I think a good comic strip is one that has all that and also tells an interesting story or captures a unique thought/opinion... that takes a stance... and has humor!
Q: Do you have any submission guidelines or standards?
A: We prefer original work that has not been published in another publication. The piece should fill a full page and must be able to stand as an independent strip. The content does not have to be Asian American, but if it's to run in an issue that is themed (food, 
politics...), than we'd like it to be related to that theme. We are looking for submissions that are creative, edgy, thoughtful and well-executed.
Q: What salary rates would you give your comic strip artists?
A: Unfortunately our entire staff is unpaid and we cannot afford to pay 
our contributors. But we can offer support, exposure and tear sheets 
for portfolios... and love!
----------
Thanks for introducing me to your site. I am always looking for ways to find Asian American comic artists and this is a great resource. A number of your featured artists have contributed to Hyphen so we are already big fans! Please let people know we are looking for a full color comic for our next issue, due our March/April!

Thanks. and keep up the good work.
*stefanie
:: stefanie hsien liang
:: art director
:: hyphen magazine
inVasian
sent: 12/16/04
to: editor@invasianjournal.com
Response 12/18/04: Thanks for your inquiry but invAsian is not in
publication at the moment. It has not been decided at
this time if we will resume publication or not.

Thanks,
Izumi Tezuka
Jade Magazine
sent: 12/16/04
to: info@jademagazine.com
Response 12/30/04: Please find below the answers to your questions.  If you have any other questions, please feel free to contact me.
Q: Is your periodical interested in Asian American comic strip
submissions?
A: While we have not had any submissions in the past, we would be open to
submissions.
Q: Do you have any submission guidelines or standards? 
A: Much like our guidelines for writers, the submissions would have to
suit our audience of professional Asian women in their 20s and 30s. We would be particularly interested in strips from Asian American women.
Q: What salary rates would you give your comic strip artists?
A: We would provide our artists with a competitive rate.

Regards,
Ellen
ellen@jademagazine.com
Juzze
sent:12/16/04
to: info@juzze.com
NO response
KoreAm Journal
sent: 12/06/04
to: info@koreamjournal.com
Response 12/21/04: Yes, we would be interested in comic strip submissions from korean americans, since we also try to use the magazine as an outlet for
korean american creative talent.  But since we're a magazine focusing on
korean americans, we would only be interested in running comic strips by
korean americans.  What we would look for is a comic strip that is well written -- that might be clever or funny -- and that might present a unique perspective on life. and it's got to be interesting visually.  The only submission standards is that the strip not include any expletives.  Unfortunately our salary rates are pretty low -- it could be anywhere between $25 to $75, mostly depending on the frequency of us running the strip.

Hope this helps.

--
Jimmy Lee
Managing Editor
KoreAm Journal
jimmy@koreamjournal.com
Korean Quarterly
sent: 12/16/04
to: editor@koreanquarterly.com
NO response
maARTe
sent: 12/16/04
to: info@maarte.org
NO response
Meniscus Magazine
sent: 12/16/04
to: meniscuszine@yahoo.com
NO response
Response 12/29/04: We'll review any content, including comic strips, submitted through the "Post an Article" link.  We do not pay for any submissions.  Anyone
hoping to have material published on our site should familiarize
themselves with the other content on our site and other literature on Asian
American empowerment.  Historically, we have summarily rejected most
submissions we have received, because they have come from people who have
found our site at random and are obviously unfamiliar with the concept of
Asian American empowerment.  Of course, appropriate submissions will be
reviewed with care.
Model Minority
sent: 12/16/04
to: modelminority@igc.org
NO response
Monolid
sent: 12/16/04
to: letters@monolid.com
Response 12/16/04: As an online magazine with a South Asian audience, we would definitely be interested in a comic strip that caters to South Asian life and culture in some way. Since we are an online magazine, we cannot pay our
contributors in any monetary way. However, what we do offer them is the
chance to be part of a vibrant, ongoing cultural dialogue that
encompasses South Asia and the greater world. What we would want in a
South Asian comic strip is clarity, humor, creativity and a message of
some sort for our intended audience. Our general guidelines are posted
on the website at www.monsoonmag.com

Feel free to e-mail me with any other questions.

Thanks,
Shikha Malaviya
Publisher/Editor-in Chief
www.monsoonmag.com
Monsoon Magazine
sent: 12/16/04
to: editor@monsoonmag.com
Response 12/17/04: Actually, this would be new for us too.  Right now, we're in
a non-profit status, simply trying to get as much membership as possible (with much success).  Our brand New York Seoul is recognized in the Korean/Asian American community.  As for accepting AA comic strip submissions, we'd be interested in Asian (especially Korean) American comic strip submissions.  You see, our audience based is mainly young Korean American professionals living in the NYC area.  A good comic strip may perhaps be the Asian/Korean American "The Boondocks".  It's amazing how this comic brought out some key issues within the Black community.  As for submissions guidelines/standards, there are none now.  So, we would work collaboratively with the artist to make both the newsletter and the comic strip shine in the best light.  As for salary rates, we will pay competitively as we look into the future (when we have a newsletter and e-zine).  But for now, we're looking for other Korean/Asian American artists who simply want exposure.

Hope that helps.  Let me know if you need anything else.

Max Han
New York Seoul
mhan@newyorkseoul.com
New York Seoul
sent: 12/16/04
to: mhan@newyorkseoul.com
Mosaic Magazine
sent: 12/16/04
to: mosaic@dolphin.upenn.edu
NO response
Northwest Asian Weekly
sent: 12/23/04
to: scpnwan@nwlink.com,
newstips@nwasianweekly.com
NO response
St. Louis Chinese American News
sent: 12/16/04
to: editor@scanews.com
NO response
Samoa News
sent: 12/16/04
to: news.admin@samoatelco.com
NO response
Yolk
sent: 12/16/04
to: shop@yolk.com
shopkeeper@yolk.com (
failed email)
NO response
Summary:
It's definitely a mixed bag.  Some say they're interested, some don't have the courtesy to respond.  Most of those interested seem to have a strict vision of what type of comic strip they'd like to feature.  Almost all of those interested claim they can't afford to pay for comic strips.  And for those who can pay, the salary is worse than chicken feed.  It's definitely possible to get published; a few of the comic strip artists who I have in my artist listings have had their work published in Asian American periodicals at one time or another.  Still, I'm a comic strip artist, and even I haven't gotten any Asian American periodicals to publish my work.  I wish I could end on a more positive outlook, yet to make things dismal again, consider this...  Do any of the above periodicals currently feature Asian American comic strips??  Not that I know of.
Home About Resources Artists Reviews Forum Contact